fbpx

Sleep is imperative to your child’s growth and as such, you should ensure that your child always lies down on a crib mattress that facilitates the best sleep possible. It should be a mattress where your child can wake up from feeling rested and refreshed, ready to learn and grow. However, with the wide range of choices available in the market today, finding the best toddler mattress can feel overwhelming.

To save you the hassle and the tantrums, we’re going to share our top 5 picks based on thousands of customer reviews as well as experiences coupled, with intensive product research and analysis. These are some of the best crib mattress models you can find out there.

We’ve also included a brief rundown of the key factors to consider when evaluating different options so that you are able to choose the most comfortable and durable crib mattress for your precious little angel. So, read on to learn more.

Top 5 Best Selling Toddler Mattress

ImageNameDimensionsWeightMaterial TypeWhere To Buy
Milliard Hypoallergenic Baby Crib Mattress52 x 27.5 x 4.8 inches
9.53 pounds
Polka DotCheck Price
Graco Premium Foam Crib Mattress27.6 x 52 x 5 inches
7 pounds
Foam
Check Price
Dream On Me Spring Toddler Mattress52 x 27 x 6 inches
12 pounds
Vinyl
Check Price
Safety 1st Toddler Bed Mattress52.5 x 27.5 x 5.5 inches
7.5 pounds
BPA Free
Check Price
Moonlight Slumber Little Dreamer27.5 x 5 x 52 inches
11 pounds
Jersey
Check Price

5 Top Rated Toddler Mattress Reviews

1. Graco Premium Foam Crib & Toddler Bed Mattress

Taking the first position on our list is the Graco Premium Foam crib and toddler mattress. This is a quality, affordable crib mattress, and an excellent choice for a toddler bed. Its top highlight is the light foam construction.

The mattress is made from a comfortable five inches thick foam which is pretty much the standard thickness for crib and toddler mattresses. However, the best part about this foam is that it’s not too firm or too soft. It has a well-balanced firmness that will support the baby’s delicate bone structure and provide a comfortable, quality sleep.

Best Toddler Mattress

The foam used to make the crib mattress is quite breathable, too, and allows for plenty of airflow. Hence, it can reduce the risk of suffocation for your little one. It will help in regulating the temperature of the mattress so as to keep your child cool and comfortable throughout the night.

On top of this, the crib mattress has a water-resistant lining which will not only makes cleaning easier but will also help keep your baby dry while sleeping. This crib mattress is also anti-static and anti-microbial. Additionally, it’s GreenGuard Gold certified. This guarantees that it’s free from phthalates and meets federal flammability standards, making it very safe for your toddler.

To sum it all, the Graco Premium Foam is one of the top quality crib mattresses you will find out there at quite an affordable price. If you want to ensure safe and comfortable sleep for your toddler, then this is definitely an option to consider.

Pros
  • Comfortable foam with just the right firmness
  • Non-toxic breathable foam to keep your child cool through the night
  • The removable cover is waterproof, soft, and comfortable
  • Designed to fit both cribs and beds, with a six-year warranty
  • GreenGuard Gold certified, and with flame retardants
Cons
  • Requires around 72 hours to expand fully
  • Has some “off-gassing” smell which can take up to 48 hours to dissipate

2. Milliard Hypoallergenic Crib Mattress and Toddler Bed Mattress

Following the Graco Premium foam mattress closely is the Milliard Hypoallergenic crib mattresses. This is another top-quality yet affordable memory foam mattress available in the market today.

To start off, it’s made from a 5-inch thick high-quality foam featuring one, uniform construction that’s firm enough to deliver optimal comfort and support for infants and toddlers. In addition, the foam performs well when it comes to edge support and will perfectly fit a standard toddler bed or crib without leaving any space on the edges.

Toddler Mattress Reviews

The crib mattress is also designed to facilitate perfect airflow, helping to regulate the temperature while the baby is sleeping as well as preventing suffocation. The foam filling has been reinforced with a polyester cover that’s breathable and waterproof. Therefore, the baby is not likely to wet the mattress and it will be easy to clean the cover.

The polyester cover is also non-porous and hypoallergenic. Unwanted allergens and dust mites will not be able to permeate the crib mattress, plus it is CertiPUR-US certified. Meaning, it’s free from any harmful chemicals and as such, safe for your baby. In short, this is an excellent crib mattress and one that we would highly recommend.

Pros
  • Hypoallergenic crib and toddler mattress
  • Its memory foam is breathable and comfortable with just the right amount of firmness
  • The foam and cover meet all safety regulations and certifications
  • With a waterproof cover that’s also easy to clean
  • The foam won’t lose its shape easily even after years of use
Cons
  • Has a lingering “off-gassing” smell that might take a few days to dissipate
  • The crib mattress cover might not be that durable

3. Dream On Me Spring Crib and Toddler Bed Mattress

The Dream On Me Spring Crib is a well-made crib mattress and probably one of the best mattresses when it comes to providing support.

It provides a firm yet comfortable sleeping surface, ideal for a baby or toddler. It’s a lightweight innerspring crib and toddler mattress made up of 80 interwoven steel coils that are heat tempered. All these coils coupled together offer an ideal foundation that provides firm support to the baby.

Best Mattress for toddler

Another amazing thing about this high-quality crib mattress is that it features full perimeter wires which ensures that the mattress does not sag. These border rods keep the edges, sides, and corners of the mattress firm. Aside from helping to maintain its shape, these also make it much safer since the edges won’t easily unravel and become a safety issue.

The Dream On Me Spring crib mattress also comes with a very handy trait, the airflow pocket which is a unique feature in relation to the other models on this list. It works to keep the crib mattress fresh without the need of using small metal vents.

What’s more, this GreenGuard Gold certified crib mattress features an easy-to-clean laminated waterproof cover that is stain-resistant and helps prevent liquids from leaking inside. It also comes with a reversible design – a firm side intended for infants, and the soft toddler side. Both are covered with polyurethane foam for optimum comfort.

Perhaps the only issue you will have with this Dream On Me crib mattress is the fact that it’s a bit noisy when bounced on. It isn’t capable of staying silent because of its spring design. That being said, it still remains a superb crib mattress for toddlers or young children, with dimensions measuring 52 x 28 x 6 inches.

Pros
  • Dual-sided – with a firm infant side and a soft toddler side
  • Hypoallergenic and very breathable featuring a waterproof cover
  • Comes with a generous 10-year warranty
  • Easy to clean and can be used for both cribs and toddler beds
  • Certified non-toxic – lead and phthalates-free
Cons
  • The springs can be a little bit loud

4. Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams White Crib & Toddler Bed Mattress

The Safety 1st Heavenly Dreams is a high-quality toddler bed and crib mattress that’s designed to offer a comfortable sleeping surface at an affordable price.

This crib mattress consists of a high-density, thermo-bonded fiber core that is made from polyester. This impressively efficient material keeps the whole mattress firm and stable, thus, allowing it to provide plenty of support to your little snoozer. It is very comfortable for little ones, too.

best twin mattress for toddler

The Heavenly Dreams crib mattress also offers great edge support. It does fit tightly in most standard-sized cribs and is very lightweight which makes it easy to move. The crib mattress is surrounded by a water-resistant polypropylene-laminated vinyl cover.

The cover is really resilient when it comes to repelling water. Diapers leaking or any bedwetting won’t be an issue. The cover is 100% vinyl which is not only very effective water and stain-resistant material but it’s equally reliable at resisting odors, too. They won’t stay there for long.

The only unfortunate thing is that the venting is not at par with the other crib mattresses on this list. It does hold a little bit of heat, but not too much to get worked up about. Nonetheless, it has a good level of airflow. And, this mattress is GreenGuard Gold certified, which means it meets the standards for low chemical emissions.

Overall, this is quite an impressive mattress particularly for the amazing support it provides to infants and toddlers. It’s also pocket friendly and despite not having any special temperature regulation features, it won’t cause any suffocations or sweating.

Pros
  • Provides ample comfort and support to the toddler
  • The mattress is made with hypoallergenic materials, complete with flame retardants
  • The vinyl cover is water, stain, and odor resistant
  • Will perfectly fit both cribs and toddler beds
  • Its phthalate and lead free – a GreenGuard Gold certified crib mattress
Cons
  • It’s not quite breathable like the other crib mattresses on this list
  • May not be one of the best mattresses for durability

5. Moonlight Slumber Dual Sided Baby Crib Mattress

This dual-sided model from Moonlight Slumber is arguably one of the most expensive crib mattress options to make this list. However, it’s definitely worth every penny if you can afford it.

It has a reversible sleep system which makes it one of the most versatile crib mattresses on the market. On one side, there is an extra firm high-density foam which is ideal for infants. Whereas, the other softer side for toddlers is composed of a more cushiony and comfortable foam.

best full mattress for toddler

The best thing about this dual firmness design is that you can switch between either side depending on how your child sleeps. The crib mattress has a standard 5-inch thickness, with the toddler side equipped with a woven nest core to allow for optimal airflow as well as temperature control.

It does offer sufficient breathability, hence, your toddler will remain cool and comfortable throughout the night. The entire crib mattress is designed with an antimicrobial nylon fabric cover that is water, stain as well as odor-resistant. Meaning, your child will be resting on a safe and comfortable surface.

The stitching on the sides of the crib mattress is extra tight. Therefore, in case you spill something on the mattress, nothing will get trapped around the edges. The only downside is that the cover is not removable. But overall, there is very little to hate about this toddler crib mattress and everything to like about it.

Pros
  • Versatile, with dual firmness that provides one side for infants and the other for toddlers
  • Seams are tightly stitched, no liquid will seep into the core layer of the mattress
  • One of the best mattresses when it comes to edge support
  • Meets all safety requirements including flammability standards
  • The nylon fabric cover is fairly breathable and waterproof
Cons
  • Cover isn’t removable, makes cleaning a bit difficult

Factors to Consider When Purchasing a Baby Mattress

Unlike an adult bed, selecting the best mattress for a toddler requires different considerations. And because of this, we are going to break things down so as to make the process much easier for you. Here are the main key things you should look for when choosing the ideal toddler mattress for your precious little angel.

 best toddler crib mattress

Mattress Material

Should you go with an innerspring crib mattress or a foam mattress? Innerspring mattresses are heavier than those made with foam, making them a little bit hard to move but they are more durable.

On the other hand, foam mattresses are lighter and fairly durable but much easier to move as well as to clean and replace linens. Generally, your choice will depend on your personal preference because both materials can be durable provided the quality is good.

Mattress Firmness and Comfort

A firm mattress with tight bedding is the ideal choice in order to prevent any chances of your child succumbing to suffocation while sleeping.

Mattress Type

a. Foam Beds

If you are going for a foam crib mattress, then you want to ensure you pick one that’s firm, heavy, and resilient. It shouldn’t be more than 6 inches thick. Also, make sure that the surface is not too soft as it might conform to the baby’s shape, increasing the chances of suffocation or Sudden Infant Death Syndrome (SIDS).

b. Innerspring Mattresses

The more the number of coils inside an innerspring mattress, generally, the firmer it is going to be. The firmness will also depend on how thick the gauge steel is, as well as other materials inside the crib mattress such as foam and padding, including the coils.

Whichever option you go with, make sure that it’s quite firm while still being comfortable so that your child can be cozy and safe when sleeping.

Fit and Edge Support

With respect to safety precautions, you want to ensure that you pick a mattress that will fit snugly into the crib or bed and has nice edge support. If it’s a bit short for the crib or there is some gap between the crib wall or the bed and the mattress, then this can be hazardous. The baby can easily get a leg or an arm wedged in the gap and end up injuring themselves.

With no proper edge support also, the baby can roll to the edge causing it to fold and trap the baby between the mattress and the crib, posing a suffocation risk. Therefore, make sure you select a standardized crib mattress that will perfectly fit in the crib, without leaving any gaps. Additionally, make certain that the entire mattress has firm edge support so that it doesn’t easily sag and give way.

Breathability

Breathability is a critical factor to consider when it comes to purchasing a toddler mattress. A baby crib mattress with very poor breathability is likely to overheat during the night and cause your child to start sweating. It’s also a potential cause of SIDS. Therefore, this is an issue that you need to take seriously.

You should only focus on mattresses that have strong venting capabilities or special venting features. A good mattress should allow for sufficient airflow so as to regulate the temperature and keep your toddler cool and cozy while sleeping. Ensure that you invest in a crib mattress that has superb breathability if you want to keep your baby safe.

Water-resistant

Given the high possibility of fluids spillage and diaper leakage, you would also want to consider getting a baby crib mattress that has good water resistance. A mattress that’s water-resistant is not only less likely to wear and tear quickly but will also make the clean-up process much easier for you.

Conclusion

Your child can only have a sound and peaceful sleep when you invest in the best toddler mattress. The most ideal pick should be firm, comfortable, well-vented, and adheres to all safety requirements and certifications for your child’s sake and your peace of mind.

There are several excellent options out there and the five models that have made this list are definitely highly recommended and should work well for infants and toddlers. However, if you have different preferences, be sure to keep the buying guide in mind to help you make a more informed decision when evaluating different choices for your baby’s crib.

Additional Resources

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *