fbpx

Best Mattress Under $500 2020 – Top 10 Comparison

Considering how important sleep is and the time you spend in snoozing, owning a great mattress is the key to your overall comfort. With the wide range of mattresses available on the market today, buying a new mattress can often be confusing particularly if you’re on a tight budget. Plus, waiting for a big sale when you are already itching to buy a new one can be a bit frustrating. As it turns out, there are actually some great choices that can be purchased without breaking the bank. That is if you know where to look.

That’s why we compiled this list to help you find the best mattress under $500. All of our ten top mattresses are selected for different reasons, to suit every individual’s varying preferences.

Top 10 Best Mattresses Under $500

1. The Puffy Original (Editor’s Choice)

The Puffy Original

Overview

  • Firmness: 7-8 on a firmness scale of 1-10 with 10 being the firmest
  • Trial Period: 101-nights
  • Warranty: Lifetime

The Puffy mattress is our #1 pick and Editor’s Choice for the best mattress under $500. This high-quality mattress is available in Twin or Twin XL size. Aside from the 101 nights of sleep trial, the company also offers a  lifetime warranty. This generous guarantee only signifies that the product will stand the test of time.

Features

With a 7-8 firmness rating, the Puffy is not considered soft, but it is designed to be comfortable in any sleeping position. The top layer of cooling cloud foam is soft enough to cradle and adapt to your shape, with the right amount of support to allow proper spinal alignment. This enhances pressure relief while you sleep and makes this bed the best firm mattress under $500. Puffy’s universal feel is ideal, too, if you share your bed with another person who doesn’t have the same sleep needs.

Another reason why we love the Puffy mattress is because of its superior ability to prevent overheating and remain temperature neutral throughout the night. Thanks to Puffy’s breathable and machine washable cover plus the top layer of gel-infused cooling Cloud foam. Additionally, the transition layer of ClimateComfort foam improves its breathability by resisting temperature fluctuation.

Lastly, Puffy manufactures the foam for their mattresses using the Variable Pressure Foaming (VPF) process which is favorable to the environment. It’s devoid of harsh chemicals that can be harmful to your health, and of course, CertiPUR-US Certified.

Pros:
  • Lifetime warranty
  • Sleeps cool
  • Designed for all sleeper types
  • Stain-resistant, zip and wash cover
  • Advanced support and pressure relief
  • CertiPUR-US certified
Cons:
  • No enhanced edge support
  • No bounce or spring

2. Allswell King (Best Hybrid)

Allswell King

Overview

  • Firmness: 4.5-6.5
  • Trial Period: 100 nights
  • Warranty: 10 years

The Allswell mattress is our top pick for the best hybrid mattress under $500. Featuring a fantastic medium-firm feel, it comes in all sizes including the California King. Also considered as the best King mattress under $500 in this rundown, the Allswell mattress is worth checking out.

Features

Each Allswell mattress features a layer of individually wrapped coils to help prevent motion transfer, regardless of the slight bounce of the material. A layer of charcoal and copper gel memory foam lays on top of the coils giving you additional support, contour, and pressure relief. This gel memory foam layer actively works to wick away moisture and keep you cool while you sleep – contrary to a traditional memory foam which has a reputation for retaining a lot of body heat.

The impressive construction of the Allswell mattress makes it a great choice for anyone looking for just the right amount of firmness in a hybrid mattress. However, even with the 10-year warranty, you should not expect lifelong durability from this bed.

Pros:
  • Excellent medium-firm feel
  • Cooling charcoal and copper gel memory foam layer
  • Individually wrapped coils
  • Designed for all sleeping positions
  • Wheels on box facilitate easy set-up
Cons:
  • May be too soft for heavier individuals
  • Less durable
  • Poor edge support

3. Brooklyn Bowery (Best Memory Foam)

Brooklyn Bowery

Overview

  • Firmness: 5
  • Trial Period: 120 nights
  • Warranty: 10 years

For the best memory foam mattress under $500, we present the Brooklyn Bowery mattress by Brooklyn Bedding. This mattress provides you with a universal medium firmness that is suitable for any type of sleeper. Aside from the Twin size mattress, the Twin XL and the Full-sized mattresses are also available.

Features

Each Brooklyn Bowery mattress is custom made in the USA and features their patented Energex foam which feels like a combination of Visco and latex foam. The Energex foam responds quickly when you shift positions on the mattress, similar to latex foam. It can also provide relief to your pressure points, as a Visco foam does. If you prefer a balance of responsiveness and pressure relief but without the bounce, the Brooklyn Bowery could be a great choice.

Considering the high quality you can expect from a company like Brooklyn Bedding, you can’t go wrong with this product. What’s more, the brand is also giving you a chance to try this bed for 120 nights. Plus, you get a 10-year warranty should you decide to buy one. It’s perfectly suitable for a student, a child, or anyone looking for a starter mattress.

Pros:
  • Open-cell foam promotes breathability
  • Highly responsive
  • Excellent pressure relief
  • Suitable for all sleeping positions
Cons:
  • Edge support could be improved
  • Retains some heat
  • May be too soft for heavier side and back sleepers

4. Casper Element (Best Cooling)

Casper Element

Overview

  • Firmness: 6.5
  • Trial Period: 100 nights
  • Warranty: 10 years

Offering a marvelous combination of support and cool comfort, Casper’s new Element mattress is designed for all types of sleepers.

Features

Considerably the best Queen mattress under $500 in this list, this Element mattress provides you with comfort, contour, support, pressure relief, and is backed by Casper’s well-known reputation for making quality bedding. In addition, the Casper Element resists heat retention. Thanks to the breathable cover and the top comfort layer of perforated AirScape foam.

Its patented AirScape foam draws heat away from your body and allows air to flow throughout the entire mattress. Hence, the temperature doesn’t build up within the inner layers and radiate to the surface. However, even with these employed techniques, the Element does still heat up a bit at night while you sleep.

Still, you can expect to get the same high-quality construction and materials that you would with their other mattresses. This one though has a simpler design and is slightly less durable. Available in Twin and Twin XL sized mattresses, you can also purchase a Full or Queen size mattress if you need more space.

Pros:
  • High quality at an affordable price
  • Backed by Casper’s stellar reputation
  • Superior breathability
  • Excellent support
  • Relieves pressure points
Cons:
  • Not for hot sleepers
  • Lower durability
  • May be too firm for smaller side sleepers

5. The Layla Double-Sided Twin

Layla Double Sided Twin

Overview

  • Firmness: Soft side – 4, Firm side – 7
  • Trial Period: 120 nights
  • Warranty: Lifetime

If you’re looking for a mattress best for almost all types of sleeping positions, check out this fantastic product from Layla.

Features

The Layla memory foam mattress features a dual-sided design that provides you with both soft and firm sides. You can flip this bed however you want. This makes it ideal for anyone who is unsure of what firmness they prefer or for a more customizable guest bedroom. Aside from the two firmness options, Layla mattresses also include varied support to target heavier regions of your body. Such areas are prone to deep compression during sleep. Additionally, each Layla mattress has a removable cover for seasonal dry cleaning.

Our favorite trait of the Layla mattress is its advanced cooling capabilities. The cover incorporates a reactive thermo-gel infusion followed by a copper gel memory foam comfort layer below on either side. Additionally, the soft side has a layer of Max Airflow support foam with deep channeling to disperse heat to the edges and out of the mattress.

What’s more, copper has antimicrobial properties. Hence, you can expect better odor control with your mattress. The Layla comes in different sizes including Twin, Twin XL, and Queen. And, each mattress entails a lifetime warranty, along with the 120-night money-back guarantee.

Pros:
  • Flippable design provides two firmness options
  • High quality with extended durability
  • Cover can be dry cleaned
  • Advanced cooling
  • Varied support for deep compression areas
Cons:
  • Soft or firm, no true medium
  • Not ideal for heavier individuals

6. Brentwood Home Cypress

Brentwood Home Cypres

Overview

  • Firmness: 6
  • Trial Period: 1 year
  • Warranty: 25 years

Our sixth pick for the best mattresses under $500 is the Cyprus Affordable Memory Foam Mattress by Brentwood Home.

Features

The Cyprus mattress can be purchased in Twin, Twin XL, or Full size.  Whichever size you choose, you get an incredible 25-year warranty plus a year of sleep trial. If you desire added height, support, or plushness from your new bed, this might be a perfect choice.

Additionally, the Cyprus memory foam mattress excels in temperature regulation, thanks to its charcoal-infused top layer foam which actively pulls heat and moisture away from your skin. To further enhance this effect, the Cyprus mattress also features a breathable cover and a thick layer of contour-cut foam. These materials increase airflow throughout the entire structure.

The mattress also uses plant-based BioFoam, too. Brentwood Home utilizes BioFoam as an alternative to traditional memory foam in an effort to minimize the environmental impact of their products. With this material, you can still have the cushiony feeling many of us have grown to love in a memory foam bed.

Furthermore, the all-foam construction of the Cyprus mattress provides excellent motion isolation to help you sleep restfully regardless of a fidgety bed partner.

Pros:
  • Advanced temperature regulation
  • Optional hybrid upgrade for added support
  • Optional height upgrade for added plushness
  • Use of environment-friendly BioFoam
  • Lengthy 25-year warranty
Cons:
  • Slow responsiveness
  • Lacking edge support
  • Not firm enough for heavier stomach sleepers

7. Flip by Nest Bedding

Flip By Nest Bedding

Overview

  • Firmness: Medium side – 5.5, Firm side – 7.5
  • Trial Period: 30 nights
  • Warranty: 10 years

Taking the seventh spot in our rundown for the best mattresses under $500 is the Flip mattress by Nest Bedding.

Features

With the amazing combination of luxury comfort and support, this dual-sided bed is truly an Amazon exclusive and the first flippable hybrid mattress featured online. The Flip offers both medium and firm sides to accommodate sleeping in all three positions, just not on the same side generally.

Moreover, the Flip mattress does a great job of resisting heat retention with its breathable cover, the top layer of cooling Visco gel foam, and the Caliber coil system below. The latter prevents heat from getting trapped inside, which usually occurs in a memory foam mattress during sleep. However, unlike other innerspring mattresses, the Flip does not have the best edge support.

It comes in Twin, Twin XL, and Full-sized Flip mattresses which fall within our featured range.

Pros:
  • Flippable design provides two firmness options for comfort
  • Reputable Nest Bedding brand
  • Enhanced cooling
  • Excellent hybrid construction
  • First flippable hybrid
Cons:
  • Brief 30-day trial
  • Poor edge support
  • Reports of uneven wear

8. Zinus Cloud Memory Foam

Zinus Cloud Memory Foam

Overview

  • Firmness: 6
  • Trial Period: None
  • Warranty: 10 years

The Zinus Cloud memory foam mattress is available in Twin, Full, Queen size, as well as King. It has three different height options: 8, 10, and 12 inches. All Zinus mattresses are OEKO TEX and CertiPUR US certified, guaranteeing that its products are chemical-free and environment-friendly.

Features

We like the Zinus Cloud bed because of its super plush feel which, as the name suggests, is almost comparable to sleeping on a cloud. Like other memory foam mattresses, the Zinus Cloud enables advanced contour and responsive support through its comfort layer. However, even with significant firmness rating, the Zinus feels a bit softer than most memory foam mattresses due to the plush, quilted microfiber cover on top.

The most unique factor of the Zinus Cloud is its use of bio memory foam in the construction. This type of memory foam is infused with green tea, purified charcoal, and natural plant oil to facilitate long-lasting freshness and odor control. You can expect comfort and refreshment after a night’s sleep on this mattress.

Pros:
  • 8″, 10″, and 12″ height options
  • Bio memory foam combats odor
  • Superb contour
  • Super plush and soft
  • Safe and environment-friendly
Cons:
  • Decompression period may take more than 48 hours
  • No in-home trial
  • Retains some heat

9. Chime Express Memory Foam

Chime Express Memory Foam

Overview:

  • Firmness: 6
  • Trial Period: None
  • Warranty: 10 years

Coming down to the ninth spot in our list of the best mattresses under $500, we have the Chime Express memory foam from Signature Design by Ashley.

Features

This memory foam mattress is available in Twin, Full, Queen, King, and California King sizes. Each size also offers varying height options including 8, 10, and 12 inches. Plus, all are compatible with any type of bed frame and base, including adjustable ones.

Unlike other memory foam mattresses, the Chime Express memory foam facilitates a pretty firm feeling bed. Sure it still contours to your shape, provides comfort, and relieves pressure. But not similar to other memory foam mattresses which do so with a softer feel. We consider this additional firmness and support as an advantage. However, if you are a smaller, lighter individual who sleeps primarily on their side, you may find this mattress is a bit too firm.

Additionally, the Chime Express offers superior motion isolation resulting from the memory foam construction. Furthermore, the Chime Express memory foam mattress comes with a breathable, hypoallergenic cover, and minimal off-gassing period.

Pros:
  • 3 different height options
  • Firmer feeling memory foam
  • Minimal off-gassing
  • Advanced comfort and motion isolation
  • Compatible with any bed frame and base
Cons:
  • No mattress in-home trial
  • Lengthy 72-hour decompression time
  • Retains some heat
  • May be too firm for smaller side sleepers

10. Sweetnight Hybrid

Sweetnight Hybrid

Overview

  • Firmness: 5-6.5
  • Trial Period: Contact seller for returns, not specified but most likely within 30 days
  • Warranty: 10 years

Finally, the Sweetnight Hybrid mattress is our final pick for the best mattress options under $500. This hybrid mattress is available in Full, Queen, and King sizes, all offering fantastic pressure relief and cool comfort.

Features

The Sweetnight made it to our top 10 list because of its super plush and soft pillow top. The material provides added comfort and allows you to luxuriously sink into the surface when you lie down. Additionally, the Island is infused with gel memory foam to help you sleep cool all night.

What’s more, all of the coils in this bed are individually wrapped. As a result, this bed has better motion isolation than other hybrid or innerspring mattresses. The coils also slightly counteract the extreme softness of the pillow top to ensure proper spinal alignment and support while you sleep.

Pros:
  • Plush pillow top
  • Gel memory foam sleeps cool
  • Excellent motion isolation
  • Supportive and responsive
  • Great for any sleeping position
Cons:
  • Requires 72-hours to fully decompress
  • Heavy, needs more than one person to set up
  • Too soft for some

A Buyer’s Guide to Buying a New Mattress

a shopper checking some bed samples

Now that you know what mattresses we recommend for under $500, let’s discuss the factors we’ve considered. The following sections will briefly go over what traits to look for when buying a mattress. Plus, the type of individuals that each bed would serve best, so you can determine which is the right one for you.

1. Firmness and Support

The firmness of a bed is often the most important trait because it affects your overall level of comfort while you sleep. You may already have an idea of whether you prefer a soft or a firm bed. But, for the most part, the firmness and support your body needs are largely determined by your sleeping position.

Side sleepers generally need a softer bed that can easily compress beneath their shoulder region. It’s typically where a large amount of weight is concentrated. Stomach and back sleepers are mostly better suited to a medium-firm or a firm bed because it keeps their hips elevated and aligned with their backs and shoulders.

The ultimate goal is to have proper spinal alignment and even support provided by the appropriate firmness level during sleep.

2. Temperature Regulation

Overheating at night can disrupt your sleep. And, with the addition of memory foam and other foams into the mattresses, temperature regulation has become a priority. Fortunately, there are several ways to prevent heat retention, to wick away moisture, and to promote airflow. These features are necessary to enable temperature neutralization or cooling effect on a mattress.

We highly recommend gel or graphite-infused foams and breathable materials in mattresses to enhance comfort. If you tend to sleep hot, as many people do, it’s wise to look for special cooling properties in your new bed. This way, you can rest undisturbed.

3. Motion Isolation

a couple sleeping soundly

Motion isolation refers to reducing energy and movement felt across the surface of your bed from one side to the other. If you sleep with a restless partner or a fidgety pet, minimizing motion transfer is important so you can sleep peacefully throughout the night. It will also come in handy if you share your bed with someone who has a different sleep schedule or you tend to be a light sleeper overall.

Most foam beds do a superior job of nearly eliminating motion transfer. Hybrid beds tend to do slightly worse. However, if the coils are individually wrapped, most of the motion transfer can be controlled before it reaches the surface.

4. In-Home Trial and Warranty Period

Buying a mattress online without testing it out first can be stressful. That’s why an in-home trial has rapidly become the new normal for buying mattresses in a box. If you wind up with a mattress you don’t like, we initially recommend sleeping on it for 2-4 weeks before making your final decision. It can take about 30 days for your body to adjust to the new bed. This is particularly true if you’ve become accustomed to your old lumpy one that has provided poor spinal alignment while you sleep.

We recommend a 10-year warranty or more because it is a good indicator of durability. If you’re going to make a large purchase, as you do with mattresses, you probably want to make sure it’s going to stand the test of time. The bed’s warranty will give you an idea of how long the mattress will last

What Mattress Will You Choose?

Now that you know what our top picks are, the best mattress under $500 that’s ideal for you will ultimately depend on your specific sleep needs. We have given you a lot to think about. Hence, before you make your final decision, let’s quickly review our #1 Editor’s Choice, the Puffy Original foam mattress, one last time.

Puffy’s stand out traits include:

  • Lifetime warranty
  • Sleeps cool
  • Designed for all sleeper types
  • Stain-resistant, zip and wash cover
  • Advanced support
  • Accurate pressure relief
  • Cleaner VPF process employed to make the foam
  • CertiPUR-US certified
  • Minimal motion transfer

The Puffy Original mattress would make an excellent choice for anyone looking to buy a highly durable mattress that doesn’t sacrifice on quality. Of course, the other mattresses on our list also make great options depending on your personal preferences.

Which will be the best mattress for your needs?

Additional Resources