Best Down Mattress Topper 2020 – Our Top 7 Picks Compared

Are you tired of going to sleep on an overly firm or hard mattress? Or is your mattress simply getting old and you want to refresh it a bit? If so, you may want to consider introducing a down and feather mattress topper to your sleeping arrangement, a cost-efficient alternative to buying a completely new mattress. The best down mattress topper could help alleviate some of your concerns and issues by giving you a fresh new super soft and plush surface to sleep on for a fraction of the price of a new mattress. Of course, the best feather mattress topper isn’t always that easy to find but that’s why we are here to help!

This article reviews some of the top down and feather mattress toppers available on the market today so you will not only see what your options are, but also compare your specific needs to each mattress topper’s features. We also take into account customer reviews from regular people just like you so you will know exactly what to expect when you make a decision.

Top 7 Best Down Mattress Toppers

Without further ado, here is our list of the best feather and down mattress toppers available today. Each of our top 7 choices should provide you with the added comfort you’d expect from a mattress topper without breaking the bank. Just remember it’s okay to spend a bit more on bedding if it results in better sleep. After all, that’s what you are aiming for, right?

1. Pacific Coast Baffled Hypoallergenic Natural-fill Queen (Editor’s Choice)

Pacific Coast Baffled Hypoallergenic Natural Fill Queen

Overview

  • Filling material: Resilia feathers
  • Shell material: 100% cotton
  • Thread count: 230

Features

The Pacific Coast Feather Company natural-fill feather mattress topper is our #1 choice among 7 contenders for best down and feather mattress topper this year. This mattress pad is easily the best feather bed on the market today for its luxury feel, superior loft, and exceptional value. Pacific Coast Feather Company also provides customers with a 30-night in-home trial and a limited 5-year warranty to back their product’s durability and guarantee your satisfaction.

This feather topper is constructed with a 230 thread count, 100% cotton shell that incorporates baffle box stitching to promote loft and prevent the displacement of feathers inside. The Resilia feather filling is springy and paired with baffle box construction to give you superior cushioning and loft for a more comfortable sleep night after night.

What makes Pacific Coast Feather Company a favorite in many feather bed topper reviews is the fact the manufacturer is also dedicated to socially responsible sourcing and production practices. Additionally, since there may be concerns about feather allergies, all Pacific Coast Feather Company products come with an allergen-free warranty. They use Hyperclean, a revolutionary cleaning method that effectively removes dust and allergens.

However, a mattress pad as soft and luxurious as this feather topper requires extra care so it doesn’t lose its form. You can spot clean it but for anything more, you will need to get it professionally dry cleaned.

Pros:
  • Excellent value
  • Springy Resilia feathers
  • 5-year limited warranty
  • Superior loft
  • Allergen-free warranty
Cons:
  • Needs professional cleaning
  • Reported size discrepancies (you may have to order one size up)
  • Needs fluffing every few days
  • Feathers not as soft as down

2. Allied Essentials 100% Cotton California King (Luxury Choice)

Allied Essentials 100% Cotton California King

Overview

  • Filling material: Down and goose feather
  • Shell material: 100% cotton
  • Thread count: 300

Features

The Allied Essentials down and goose feather mattress topper is our #2 pick and our top luxury choice. We love this mattress pad because of its luxury ultra-soft feel that provides extra loft and a plush sleeping surface. This fluffy feather bed topper also comes with a 30-night, in-home trial so you can be sure it’s worth the added cost.

The shell of the Allied Essentials mattress topper is made with 300 thread count 100% cotton. This mattress topper also utilizes a baffle box construction to increase loft and prevent the filling from shifting in the blanket for a more even sleeping surface at night. The internal filling of this mattress topper is dual-layered. The bottom layer, made from goose feathers, helps maintain loft and durability. The white down-filled top layer, on the other hand, provides you with a supportive and soft sleeping surface free from any sharp quills.

Allied Essentials’ feather and goose down mattress topper boasts a dense 550 fill power so it shouldn’t need frequent fluffing. Even though the filling is dense, this mattress topper still does a great job at regulating temperature due to its breathable, 300 thread count cotton shell material that retains minimal heat and has moisture-wicking properties.

The Allied Essentials down and feather topper is machine- washable. Not only is this convenient, but also helps to promote a more hypoallergenic and sanitary sleeping environment.

Pros:
  • Luxurious quality and feel
  • Machine-washable
  • Breathable
  • Dual-layered feather and down filling
  • Moisture-wicking
Cons:
  • Higher price tag
  • Needs an initial airing out period
  • Inconsistent sizing

3. Sweet Jojo Designs Baffle Box Queen (Budget Choice)

Sweet Jojo Designs Baffle Box Queen

Overview

  • Filling material: 95% goose feathers and 5% goose down
  • Shell material: 100% cotton
  • Thread count: 240

Features

The Sweet Jojo Designs Goose Feather Mattress Topper is our pick for the best feather topper for anyone on a budget. Due to its soft feel and quality construction, this mattress topper can transform your bed and let you sink in deep sleep¬†without leaving a gaping hole in your wallet. In lieu of the usual 30-night risk-free trial period given by most manufacturers, this topper is eligible for Amazon’s 30-day return policy if ordered through their site.

The 240 thread count cover is 100% cotton, making the Sweet Jojo Designs mattress topper breathable and effective at regulating temperature so it will cool you down if you tend to sleep hot. The filling – 95% white goose feather and 5% goose down – is softer and more comfortable than a feathers-only topper.

Keeping the filling in place is the shell’s baffle box construction and end-to-end stitching. This technique keeps the filling in place and evenly distributed within the shell, adding to the topper’s breathability while maintaining its shape.

However, a disadvantage of this topper is that you may need to fluff it regularly. For it to remain fluffy and soft, we recommend fluffing at least once per week.

Lastly, the Sweet Jojo Designs feather mattress topper is machine-washable and relatively easy to clean. When drying in a machine we recommend adding a couple of tennis balls to the load to help maintain and refresh its fluffiness.

Pros:
  • Very affordable
  • Baffle box construction
  • Uses breathable 100% cotton
  • Down and feather combination
  • Can be machine-washed and dried
Cons:
  • Only available in 2 sizes
  • Quills may poke through without a cover
  • No warranty
  • Thinner than some of the other options

4. Millsave Hotel Quality Baffled Queen

Millsave Hotel Quality Baffled Queen

Overview

  • Filling material: 5% goose down and 95% goose feather
  • Shell material: Cotton and polyester
  • Thread count: 233

Features

The Millsave down and feather mattress topper makes our list, thanks to its ultra-high loft that makes it softer and more comfortable. This down and goose featherbed features a 233 thread count 100% cotton top while the sides and bottom are made from 100% polyester. If you’re concerned that polyester retains heat than natural fibers, you need not worry because the cotton top will wick excess moisture away from your skin while you sleep. The mixed filling of the Millsave feather topper consists of 95% white goose feather and 5% white down to provide durability, support, and softness. In addition, it comes in a baffle box design to keep feathers in place so you sleep on a level surface night after night.

Another great feature of this mattress topper is its internal liner. The liner maintains comfort by preventing feathers from poking through the shell or completely leaking out. The liner is somewhat effective but as with all feather mattress toppers, you can still expect some leakage.

Just like the other goose down and feather toppers available on the market, you can expect this topper to be washable, albeit, no information is listed.

Furthermore, we highly recommend you double-check the sizing before you order though Millsave charges for return shipping as well as a restocking fee.

Pros:
  • High 5″ loft
  • Uses a mixture of goose feathers and down
  • Affordable
  • Extra plush 550 fill power
  • Baffle box construction
Cons:
  • Many reports of feathers leaking
  • Used polyester on sides and bottom
  • High shipping cost
  • Shipping and restocking fees charged for returns
  • No available care instructions

5. Hotel Grand Baffle Box 5-inch Gusset Queen

Hotel Grand Baffle Box 5-inch Gusset Queen

Overview

  • Filling material: White Duck down and feather
  • Shell material: 100% cotton
  • Thread count: 233

Features

The Hotel Grand feather and down-filled mattress topper is our #5 pick for the best feather top mattress pads. We chose this product because it is affordable, comfortable, and durable. This down and feather topper has an impressive 5″ inch loft, owing to a fill power of 500.

However, even with the enhanced thickness of this Hotel Grand feather mattress topper, it still remains breathable and very comfortable, thanks to its 233 thread count purely cotton shell. The filling, as mentioned, consists of both white duck down and feathers. The down used in the topper’s pillow top gives the softest feel possible while the feathers in the base provide added support.

One thing we noticed is that in this feather and down filled mattress topper, the baffle box construction doesn’t go all the way to the bottom, thus, some shifting is expected. For optimal comfort, we recommend fluffing this feather and down topper every day.

Hotel Grand offers complimentary shipping with this mattress topper and while it does not provide information on a warranty you can always use the 30-day Amazon return policy if you order through the site.

It is also important to note that given the extra thickness and weight of this feather topper, loading it into your washing machine at home may be a bit of a challenge. However, your washer can probably handle it although it’s not mentioned anywhere in Hotel Grand’s product page.

Pros:
  • Extra high 5″ loft
  • Ulta-soft and plush down top
  • Affordable
  • 100% cotton shell
  • Free shipping
Cons:
  • No care instructions available
  • No warranty information
  • Baffle box stitching does not go all of the way through
  • Possible size discrepancies

6. Bluestone 4-inch Gusset Queen

Bluestone 4-inch Gusset Queen

Overview

  • Filling material: 95% duck feathers and 5% duck down
  • Shell material: 100% cotton
  • Thread count: 233

Features

Next in our Top 7 down mattress toppers list is the Bluestone down and duck feather mattress topper. This down and feather topper stands out in a sea of feather mattress toppers because it provides a plush sleeping surface, uses both down and feathers, is encased in a 100% cotton shell, and reasonably-priced.

Quality-wise, this feather bed features a 233 thread count 100% cotton shell that adds smoothness while preventing the filling from shifting elsewhere. The breathable cover also aids in thermoregulation so you’re kept cool and dry. Like the other feather toppers on our list, the Bluestone feather bed also features a baffle box stitching design to help keep the feathers in place so you can sleep on an even surface. The Bluestone down and feather mattress topper is filled with 95% duck feathers and 5% duck down for extra comfort.

Another advantage the Bluestone down and duck feather bed has over other toppers is its super high 4″ gusseted sides. The amplified height of the sides helps this down and feather mattress topper remain plush to provide you with the softness and support your body needs for a night of deep sleep.

There is no warranty on this product but it does comply with Amazon return policies.

Pros:
  • Very affordable
  • Ample mix of down and feathers
  • Baffle box design
  • Soft and breathable cotton cover
  • Lightweight yet comfortable
Cons:
  • Fill power information not available
  • No warranty
  • Not 4″ thick as advertised
  • Prone to occasional leaking

7. Rose Premium Hypoallergenic Baffled Overfilled Queen

Rose Premium Hypoallergenic Baffled Overfilled Queen

Overiew

  • Filling material: 20% goose down and 80% goose feather
  • Shell material: 100% organic cotton
  • Thread count: 233

Features

The Rose Feather goose down and feather mattress topper may our last pick for the best feather toppers but it still packs a lot of features. As far as feather mattress toppers go, this one has quite a few added perks. We love this mattress topper because it is affordable, plush, and has more down than any of the other feather toppers on our list.

The Rose Feather mattress topper features a 100% organic cotton cover with 233 thread count. The cover has an added anti-allergy coating to help ensure you won’t have a reaction to the natural goose down and feathers. Additionally, the cover features four elastic anchor bands in the corners so you can attach it to your mattress and help keep it in place, even if you tend to change positions frequently throughout the night.

This mattress topper is filled with 80% white goose feathers for support and 20% white goose down – four times more than the other down and feather toppers on our list – for added comfort. The added down makes it softer and some say it comes close to what sleeping on a cloud would feel like. The edges are double stitched to help keep the feathers in and minimize leakage as well.

Rose Feather guarantees that all of their goose feathers and goose down have come from the food industry and that they adhere to a ‘no live-plucking’ policy. Lastly, similar to the other feather mattress toppers featured in this comparison guide, the Rose Feather goose down and feather topper can easily be machine-washed and tumble-dried.

Pros:
  • Elastic anchor bands in corners
  • 100% organic cotton cover
  • Non-live plucked products guaranteed
  • 20% more down filling than other down mattress brands
  • Anti-allergy coating
Cons:
  • Not as thick as some would like
  • Requires a thick cover to prevent being poked
  • Needs to air out for a couple days to reduce natural odor

How to Choose the Right Mattress Topper for You: A Buyer’s Guide

Now that you have read our reviews on mattress toppers you are probably ready to decide which one is the best down mattress topper or best feather mattress topper for you. However, before you make your purchase, here’s a guide that will answer all your questions about how you can choose the right mattress topper for your needs.

Why Buy a Mattress Topper?

couple in mattress store

If you are wondering why you should buy a mattress topper, there are several reasons. For many, sleep increasingly becomes more uncomfortable when their mattresses start to wear down, whether it is a memory foam mattress or another type. Maybe you bought a mattress that’s too firm or hard for your liking, or maybe you just prefer sleeping in a plush, luxurious bed. Whatever your reason is, a mattress topper is a logical solution, because it solves the problem while eliminating the need to replace an entire bed.

If you prefer more of a contoured feel with lots of support you may want to consider a latex or foam mattress topper. If you want to sleep extra cool a memory foam topper or latex topper with a gel option could be better suited for your needs. Lastly, if you prefer to have more bounce in your toppers, then a latex one suits you best,

However, if you put a premium on extra support, durability, and maintaining a cool sleeping surface, consider getting a down or feather mattress topper, or one that combines both down and feathers in its fill.

Down Filled Mattress Topper vs Feather Filled Mattress Toppers

What’s the difference between down and feather topper? Is there a huge difference between feather-filled or down-filled toppers? And what makes the best mattress topper?

While feather filling is by no means hard or firm, it is more structural and supportive than down filling. This is why most people prefer having a good amount of feathers in their mattress toppers. Without them, down would simply compress and lose nearly all of its loft when you lie down. As we briefly mentioned above, feathers also have larger and more quills than down so the quills could poke through the fabric. Still, do take note that feathers in the filling keep the mattress topper level, proving support and pressure point relief.

Down filling in a mattress topper helps diminish some of the poking caused by the feathers while also providing a soft, cloud-like feel for better sleep and rest. This is why most people prefer feather toppers that also include down.

So do you prefer added support, better spinal alignment, or a fluffy feel? Choose more feathers if you like additional support and more down if you like additional fluffiness.

What is Fill Power?

When shopping for down and feather mattress toppers you will often find products, you’ll encounter the term ‘fill power.’ What does this mean, exactly? Fill power is how we measure the fluffiness or loft of a feather or down product. More specifically, fill power, measured in cubic inches, refers to the amount of space 1 ounce of down or feathers occupies. So, down and feather toppers with a higher fill power will have more loft, more comfortable, and fluffier for longer.

Fill power usually ranges between 300 for lightweight and low-end products, and goes as high as 900 in high-end luxury feather toppers and blankets.

Fill power can also alert you to the warmth of a feather or down product when you are looking at comforters. The higher the fill power, the warmer it will be.

All You Need to Know About Baffle Box Construction

baffle box construction in bedding

You read a lot about baffle box stitching in our reviews but what is it and why is it so important? When a mattress topper utilizes baffle box construction, it is sewn using additional strips of fabric between the top and bottom layers in a checkered pattern to create individual box-shaped compartments throughout its length. This is great for down and feather bedding because it eliminates excessive shifting and bunching of the filling. Cold spots and empty spaces in a topper reduces comfort and breathability. Worse, a sleeping surface that isn’t level can lead to improper spinal alignment.

Do Feather Mattress Toppers Need a Cover?

white mattress topper

Many feather mattress toppers can seriously benefit from an additional cover due to the pointy quills found in feathers and down. Of course, simply putting a fitted sheet over the top will help some, especially if the mattress topper has down as the top layer which has smaller and fewer sharp quills. However, something thicker like a thin wool blanket will add a layer of protection from any quills that may leak and poke through.

A Quick Review

You have reached the end of our best down mattress topper list and should now be ready to make a decision. Or at the very least know what you are looking for that will suit your specific needs and preferences. But before you click on any links and continue on, here’s a quick review of the Editor’s Choice for the best feather mattress topper on the market right now.

We really love Pacific Coast Feather Company mattress topper because:

  • It offers excellent value for the affordable price
  • Springy Resilia feathers mean this mattress topper is plush, supportive, and requires minimal fluffing
  • It comes with a 5-year limited warranty and a 30 night in-home trial period
  • It has superior loft
  • The allergen-free warranty guarantees you won’t have complications returning the mattress topper if it triggers your allergies
  • It uses Hyperclean feathers
  • The100% cotton cover helps promote temperature regulation
  • Pacific Coast Feather Company is committed to socially responsible sourcing and production practices

Considering all of the down and feather mattress toppers on our list and available on the market today, you are now able to make an informed decision on what mattress topper to purchase based on your needs. We hope our research helped you to narrow down your choices, allowing you to purchase the best topper so you can start reaping the benefits of restful sleep.

Additional Resources