Best Down Comforter 2019: Our Top 7 Choices Compared

|

Last Updated on

When looking for a great comforter, you should seriously consider down for the filling. Down comforters are known for being durable, warm, soft, lightweight, and luxurious. The best down comforter will encompass all of these traits, but how do you choose between the different options available in the market today? Sifting through all of the choices can often be daunting, but don’t worry, we can help!

Our top 7 down comforter reviews will explain what makes each one of them so great so you can skip the exhausting internet search. We will also talk about the traits you should look for when considering a new blanket purchase. To establish our list of top-rated down comforters we graded the products based on the filling material, available sizes, the length of the in-home trial period, the warranty length, and the manufacturer’s origin. We also included details like the season it can be used, the design and stitching, the material used to make the shell, and any other stand out characteristics.

Whether you are searching for a heavy comforter for winter, a light comforter for summer, or a comforter for year-round use, we have got you covered. Keep reading to discover what we learned so you can make an informed decision that will suit your specific sleep needs.

Top 7 Best Down Comforters

1. Tuft & Needle Insert (Editor’s Choice)

Tuft & Needle Duvet InsertOverview

  • Filling material: Humanely sourced North American down feathers
  • Available sizes: Twin/Twin XL, Full/Queen, King/California King (all options are oversized)
  • In-home trial period: 100 nights
  • Warranty length: 2 years
  • Manufacturer origin: Crafted in the USA

We chose the Tuft & Needle Down Duvet Insert to top our list of the best down blankets for several reasons. First, it is available in two weights: light and medium Both has a fill power of 650 making them versatile and able to meet your specific and seasonal needs. We also chose the light option of this comforter as our top choice for best lightweight down comforter and best down comforter for summer.

Features

This duvet uses a baffle-box construction design to maintain loft over time. This kind of structure ensures your blanket will look plush after extended use by preventing it from compressing and flattening with use.

The shell material on the duvet is made from 100% cambric cotton in a percale weave which promotes breathability while simultaneously wicking away moisture when necessary. Paired with the down feathers, this blanket will keep you warm without preventing airflow which could lead to overheating.

While we enjoyed the oversized design of the Tuft & Needle Down Duvet Insert, some consumers have complained about needing to purchase a new duvet cover to accommodate the additional dimensions.

Pros:
  • Honest pricing makes this comforter affordable on most budgets
  • Light and Medium weight available
  • Humanely sourced North American down feathers
  • Wicks away moisture to prevent overheating
  • 100 night in-home trial period with 2-year warranty
Cons:
  • Light fill means you may need a supplemental blanket on cold winter nights
  • Medium fill may be too warm for hot summer nights
  • May not be affordable on a tight budget

2. Egyptian Bedding Luxurious Goose (Warmest and Heaviest)

Egyptian Bedding LuxuriousOverview

  • Filling material: Goose down
  • Available sizes: Twin, Queen, King, California King
  • In-home trial period: 30 days
  • Warranty length: Unavailable
  • Manufacturer origin: Unavailable

We chose Egyptian Bedding’s Goose Down Comforter as our choice for the warmest down comforter. When it comes to heavy down comforters, and keeping you warm in the coldest weather, this brand does not disappoint by stuffing their comforter with a 750+ fill power.

Features

This comforter uses a baffle box design in the construction to help eliminate cold spots in the blanket and to aid in maintaining fluffiness over time. This comforter also employs a double-needle stitch throughout to prevent any down feathers from leaking out of the encasement.

The shell material is 1200 thread count, 100% Egyptian cotton. Although this is one of the best comforters for winter months, the cotton cover still promotes breathability so you won’t overheat. Egyptian cotton paired with a high thread count in the fabric also denotes quality and lasting power.

Although this comforter is only available in limited sizes, it should still suit your needs. Remember to always size up for total coverage and added loft. Also, there is no available information regarding manufacturer origin.

Pros:
  • Keeps you warm in the coldest part of the year
  • The high number of threads in the fabric adds durability
  • 30-day satisfaction guarantee
  • 100% Egyptian cotton shell
  • Affordable and high quality
Cons:
  • Too warm for year-round use
  • No warranty period
  • Limited sizes available

3. Rosecose Luxurious Cotton (Best All-Season)

Rosecose LuxuriousOverview

  • Filling material: Goose down
  • Available sizes: Twin, Queen, King
  • In-home trial period: 30 days
  • Warranty length: Unavailable
  • Manufacturer origin: Unavailable

The Rosecose Down Comforter is our pick for the best all season down comforter. It has just the right amount of fill power which is 750+. It will keep you warm in the winter without being too warm for summer. Seems impossible, right? But down comforter reviews of this brand confirms it can be done. The Rosecose Comforter’s ability to suit all-season use also makes this one of the best down comforters for hot sleepers.

Features

The sewn-through stitching found in the comforter helps to keep down in place so your blanket does not develop cold spots when you move around.

Additionally, the shell material of this comforter is made with 1200 thread count and is 100% cotton. The cotton material actively works to promote breathability and the high thread count in the fabric ensure lasting durability in this product so you can be confident in your decision to purchase.

The Rosecose comforter only comes in three size options, but it will suit almost anyone’s needs. Simply size up for added ease of movement. However, this may not be the right choice if you have a California King. Also, there is no available information regarding warranty and manufacturer origin.

Pros:
  • Suitable for year-round use
  • Affordable on most budgets
  • The high number of threads in the fabric adds durability
  • !00% cotton shell
  • Sewn-through stitching prevents excessive shifting of down filling
Cons:
  • Not openly cruelty-free
  • Limited sizing options
  • A slight odor may need to be aired out upon arrival

4. Snowman Solid White (Best Luxury)

Snowman Solid White GooseOverview

  • Filling material: White goose down
  • Available sizes: Twin, Queen, King
  • In-home trial period: 30 days
  • Warranty length: Unavailable
  • Manufacturer origin: Unavailable

The Snowman White Goose Down Comforter is our choice for the best luxury option. As one of the best goose down comforters available, it is durable and of high quality. This comforter has a 700+ fill power that makes it fluffy and suitable for year-round use.

Features

It utilizes a baffle box design to help promote lasting loft and to prevent the down from shifting and creating cold spots in the blanket.

Aside from that, the comforter shell material is 100% cotton with a 600 thread count weave. The cotton helps to ensure breathability and airflow throughout the blanket while the elevated number of threads in the fabric helps add to the overall durability of the product.

The Snowman White Goose Down Comforter is only available in limited sizes. However, it is available in several colors: coffee, khaki, blue, purple, and white. This allows you to customize your comforter to fit into your bedroom’s decor or color scheme without the need to buy an additional duvet cover.

On the other hand, the actual comforter is thinner than the pictures would lead you to believe so it might be too light during really cold nights.

Pros:
  • Suitable for use year-round
  • Available in varying colors so you don’t need a duvet cover
  • Affordable on most budgets
  • Luxurious feel and appearance
  • Baffle box stitching promotes loft and maximum fluffiness
Cons:
  • Crisp material is a bit noisy
  • May be too light for the coldest winter nights
  • Has a slight odor that dissipates with time

5. Basic Beyond All-Season Premium (Best Value)

Basic Beyond All-Season PremiumOverview

  • Filling material: Goose down
  • Available sizes: Twin, Queen, King
  • In-home trial period: 30 days
  • Warranty length: Unavailable
  • Manufacturer origin: Unavailable

Next up on our list of down comforter reviews is the Basic Beyond Goose Down Comforter. With a 650+ fill power, this comforter is perfect for all-season use. It is also available in two weight options: light-warm and warmer. This means you can choose the one that suits your individual sleep needs best. Usually, when it comes to buying a real down comforter, the price only reflects the quality of the craftsmanship. However, this brand manages to provide exceptional quality without an exorbitant price tag making it our best value choice.

Features

It has a box stitch design to prevent excessive downshifting. This comforter also has navy-colored satin piped edges and needle stitching which helps to prevent down leakage, even after extended use. The reinforced barrier on the edges works extremely well and can save you a lot of time when you clean your duvet cover.

The shell material is made with 100% cotton to promote breathability and has a thread count of 233.

The Basic Beyond Comforter is only available in three sizes but it should accommodate your needs in most scenarios. Also, there is no available information regarding warranty and manufacturer origin.

Pros:
  • Exceptional value for the price
  • Multiple weights for customizable warmth
  • Fluffs up nicely
  • Box stitching prevents cold spots
  • 100% cotton shell promotes breathability
Cons:
  • Has an odor that dissipates with time
  • Crisp material is noisy
  • Low number of threads in the fabric means it may not hold up over time

6. Beckham Luxury Hotel Collection (Best Heavy Choice)

Beckham Luxury Hotel CollectionOverview

  • Filling material: Down alternative poly-fiber
  • Available sizes: Twin/Twin XL, Full/Queen, King/ California King
  • In-home trial period: 30 days
  • Warranty length: Unavailable
  • Manufacturer origin: Unavailable

The Beckham Hotel Collection Heavyweight Goose Down Alternative Comforter is our best heavy down alternative choice. In fact, it is the only down alternative comforter to make our list due to down alternative’s reduced durability and quality compared to natural animal down.

Features

This comforter is designed for use during the winter. It is thick, fluffy, and heavy enough to keep you warm on the coldest nights, in the coldest climates. It uses a box design on the shell’s stitching to prevent shifting of the filling, even after washing.

One peculiar thing about this product is its failure to list the shell material anywhere in the product information. This would lead most people to believe it is made from a synthetic material although this is of no certainty. Regardless of the shell material, heat retention is key in a heavy comforter and this comforter surely accomplishes that goal.

It is only available in three sizes. However, they are oversized so you will have plenty of extra space and room underneath the covers to move around.

You should take extra care when washing this comforter as some consumers report issues with machine washing.

Pros:
  • Animal-friendly down alternative
  • Its heavy weight makes it great for the coldest winter nights
  • Oversize dimensions give you plenty of room to move around
  • Exceptional price makes it great for all budgets
  • Fluffy and thick
Cons:
  • Down alternative is not as durable as real down
  • Not suitable for hot summer nights
  • Slight chemical smell needs to dissipate after arrival

7. Egyptian Cotton All-Season Pinch Pleat (High-Quality Choice)

Egyptian Cotton All-Season Pinched PleatOverview

  • Filling material: Goose down
  • Available sizes: Twin, Queen, King
  • In-home trial period: 30 days
  • Warranty length: Unavailable
  • Manufacturer origin: Unavailable

Last on our list of down comforter reviews is the Egyptian Cotton Factory Outlet Store Goose Down Comforter. It has a 750+ fill power with a medium weight that makes it ideal for year-round use.

Features

It employs a baffle box stitching paired with a pinch pleat design cover. This establishes maximum loft that lasts and does not allow downshifting which can create cold spots in your blanket. The pinch pleat design also provides a pleasing aesthetic element of the comforter when used without a duvet cover.

The shell material is made with 1200 thread count, 100% Egyptian cotton. It is designed to be extremely breathable and durable. Additionally, the shell has a double stitch design to promote long-lasting durability while also preventing and down feather leakage.

This comforter is only available in three sizes so make sure to size up for maximum comfort and coverage. Also, there is no available information regarding warranty and manufacturer origin.

Pros:
  • High-quality construction ensures durability
  • 100% Egyptian cotton shell is soft and breathable
  • Medium weight is suitable for year-round use
  • Pinch pleat design is aesthetically pleasing and helps promote maximum loft
  • Double stitch design prevents down leakage
Cons:
  • Noisy material inside comforter
  • Squares are larger than normal causing more downshifting
  • May need to be tumble-dried to reach full loft

Down Comforter FAQs

Now that you have seen our top choices, let’s explore everything you need to know when purchasing a new down comforter. This includes the terms we used while comparing the comforters such as words which may be new to you and pertinent information to keep in mind when owning a down comforter. We will also discuss why particular traits should be important when shopping for a new down comforter that will suit your specific needs.

1. What Is Down?

hands full of downFirst things first, let’s establish exactly what down is. Down feathers are found underneath the top layer of feathers, generally near the chest and underbelly of a bird. Down is a fantastic insulator that is soft, fluffy, and durable.

Down feathers are mainly sourced from geese but can also come from ducks. Goose down is usually more expensive than duck down because most geese have larger, fluffier tufts of down. It can be used as filling comforters, pillows and such.

2. What Are the Different Types of Down Filling?

Most high quality down comforters are made from 100% natural down feathers, but you may come across a couple of other differences. Let’s see the variations of down filling you can expect to find in a down comforter.

a. Pure Down Filling

Down filling is exactly that, 100% natural down. This is considered to be the highest quality, most durable, and longest-lasting down filling option. Even without the word pure or 100%, a comforter that does not specify otherwise but only uses the word down will still be a pure down comforter due to regulations in place concerning how down products like pillows and comforters are made and labeled to ensure industry standards.

b. Down Filled

A down-filled comforter refers to a specific blend of feathers and down: 10% feather, 90% down. While feathers are not as durable as down, they do provide a lot of loft. Therefore, the fluffiest down comforter may be down-filled. Feathers also have quills, down does not. Note that feather filling with quills might poke through the covering at one point or another.

c. Synthetic Down

Synthetic materials can be constructed to mimic down and they do quite a good job. However, synthetic down is not as durable and will break down faster. Synthetic down does eliminate any allergens, which some people have problems with when using natural down. Synthetic options are generally much more affordable as well.

3. What Is Fill Power?

a couple lying in bedFill power is a great way to determine the potential loft and warmth capabilities of a comforter. Fill power is measured by determining how much space, or volume, an ounce of down occupies. Higher fill power equals more warmth and greater loft. Let’s look at the fill power range and expectations in more detail.

a. 400 and Below

A fill power this low will not provide a lot of warmth and should only be used on warm summer nights.

b. 400-599

This range of fill power is generally still best used for warmer months. There may be some exceptions on the higher end of this range, but for the most part, these are still considered lightweight comforters.

c. 600-799

Most consider this to be the ideal fill power range for down comforters. This range will provide great warmth without being entirely unaffordable. The low end of this range is best for hot sleepers.

d. 800+

A comforter with 800+ fill power will be very fluffy, very warm, and last for a long time. Of course, you will pay a bit more but the luxury will be well worth it for many people.

4. What Material Is Used for Comforter Encasing?

When it comes to determining which comforters are high quality and would help give you deep sleep, you should always take into consideration what the blanket’s shell material is made from as well as the number of threads in the fabric.

Generally speaking, you will want to choose a down comforter that has a natural material, like cotton, for the shell. Cotton helps to promote breathability throughout the blanket while you sleep so you can stay warm without overheating. Natural materials also help to wick away moisture in case of overheating. If you tend to sleep hot, you should prioritize a shell material that is breathable and natural. Synthetic materials, like polyester, will retain heat and prevent fresh air from penetrating the inside of the comforter.

Thread count will also help alert you to the quality of the material used in the comforter’s shell. The higher the thread count in a fabric, the denser the material is, leading to enhanced durability and added comfort.

5. What Kind of Stitches Should You Look For?

down blanket close upOften comforters will list the type of stitching used during construction, particularly with down products, to alert you to the quality and functionality of the product. Let’s look at two kinds of stitches.

a. Sewn Through Stitching

This goes through the entire comforter, top to bottom, to create compartments for isolating down and keeping it more evenly spread throughout the entire blanket.

b. Baffle Box Stitching

This kind of stitching creates isolated pockets for keeping down in place. However, instead of the top and bottom materials being sewn together, they are held together by smaller pieces of fabric. This creates more space inside the blanket which results in a higher loft and a fluffy comforter.

All About Down Comforters

1. How to Care for Your Down Comforter

children under the coversThere is an ongoing debate about the effect of machine washing down products vs dry cleaning, but for the most part, people agree you can disregard the dry cleaning label that comes on many down comforters and simply wash down products at home. Of course, if the comforter you purchase already recommended machine washing, just go for it!

2. Down Comforter Sizing

Generally, comforters will come in sizes that correlate with the accompanying bed size. Make sure you buy a comforter that is at least the size of your mattress. It is also okay to size up when it comes to blankets and comforters, especially if you sleep with a partner and one or both of you tend to shift positions throughout the night. Our list of down comforter reviews frequently recommends sizing up due to limited sizing availability in many varies comforter companies.

3. In-Home Trial Length, Warranty, and Durability

The idea of being able to purchase a blanket that comes with an in-home trial period and warranty is fairly new. As a result, not all companies will provide this incredible perk with their products. However, those that do will be leaps and bounds ahead of the competition by simply offering this additional service included in the price of the blanket.

A lengthy warranty and trial period notify you as the consumer that the product is well made, and will last. Therefore, the best quality down comforter will almost certainly offer a trial period and warranty.

4. Importance of Manufacturer Information

Where your new down comforter is made could be an important factor to look out for. Not only can the origin country denote quality, but it can also help you determine how the down is sourced. For example, countries like the United States of America are known for producing high quality, durable products which are ethically sourced. The USA may also have higher standards regarding animal cruelty compared to other countries that are also producing goose down blankets.

Choose Complete Comfort

close up of folded Turf & Needle InsertBefore we close our article, let’s quickly go over what we have learned and see why the Tuft & Needle down duvet insert is our number one choice.

When shopping for a down comforter, remember to pay attention to whether it is pure down, down-filled, synthetic down. Always remember that pure down filling is the softest, fluffiest, and most durable type of filling. Consider the material and thread count on the comforter’s shell. Also, take into account whether or not the comforter comes with a trial period and a warranty. Lastly, you may want to consider where the blanket is made and how the down is sourced.

Here is a quick review of why Tuft & Needle is the best down comforter for us:

  • Honest pricing makes this comforter affordable on most budgets
  • Light and Medium weight available for customizable warmth
  • Humanely sourced North American down feathers
  • 100% cotton shell with percale weave wicks away moisture to prevent overheating
  • 100 night in-home trial period with a 2-year warranty
  • Oversized for added comfort
  • Baffle box design for maximum loft

We hope all of the information from our down comforter reviews will help you to determine whether a product is the right choice for you. May it help you decide which specific comforter will best suit your individual needs so you can sleep cozy and comfortable.

Additional Resources

Leave a Comment