When comparing the increasingly popular mattresses from brands like Tuft & Needle and Casper, it quickly becomes apparent that these mattresses have a lot in common. It is their differences that may not be so obvious at first. That’s why we wrote this Tuft and Needle vs Casper mattress review to help you determine what makes them unique, without relying solely on their customer ratings. The aim of this head-to-head comparison of Tuft and Needle and Casper mattresses is to help you shorten your search for the perfect mattress. But first, let’s briefly introduce the two mattresses.
The Tuft and Needle Original
The Tuft and Needle Original mattress is a dual-layered foam mattress that boasts a universal firmness and feels that aims to make sleeping in any position comfortable. The Tuft and Needle Original mattress put a premium on temperature regulation, support, and pressure relief – criteria that are highly important for many sleepers.
The Casper Mattress
The Casper mattress, on the other hand, consists of 4 layers of foam and features a medium-firm feel that most users will find comfort in any sleeping position. The Casper mattress also delivers when it comes to supporting, pressure relief, ease of cleaning, and overall comfort.
Tuft and Needle vs Casper Mattress: Features Compared
Both of these mattress companies also have a reputation for providing consumers with quality, affordable products.
We have assessed both brands and the following sections will compare both based on specific traits for you to better understand how these mattresses differ. Then, you’ll be able to figure out whether it’s a Tuft & Needle or a Casper mattress that addresses your needs. This Casper vs Tuft and Needle comparison covers different factors such as construction, temperature regulation, firmness, motion isolation, and price point, among others.
It is important to note that this guide only evaluates the Tuft and Needle mattress. Tuft and Needle has two other models, Mint and Hybrid.
So, which mattress do you think wins in this Casper vs Tuft & Needle comparison? Let’s take a look at the most important features.
Let’s begin with the basics and first go over what materials are used to make both the Casper and Tuft and Needle foam mattresses to give us an idea of what we should expect from each foam bed.
Tuft and Needle’s foam mattress consists of two layers of foam and an ultra-soft breathable cover. The top layer is made from Adaptive foam, a type of comfort layer that’s infused with graphite and cooling gel. This proprietary foam material in the Tuft and Needle mattress helps maintain proper spine alignment and breathability, improving overall comfort. The base layer is made with open-cell support foam which also aids in breathability while forming a durable and supportive foundation.
Casper mattresses consist of four layers of foam that incorporate contour cuts and five varying zones of support, all of which are encased in a durable knit polyester cover. The top layer is made with a breathable open-cell foam, giving the bed a bouncy feel while the responsive high-density memory foam underneath it provides support, contour, and pressure relief. The third layer uses Adaptive transition foam to enhance even weight distribution; the base is made with durable support foam with zoned support to enhance spine alignment and provide you with an even, comfortable sleeping surface.
What we think: No one wins in this category as Tuft & Needle and Casper mattresses both use top quality materials.
The firmness of a mattress is often the first thing we look at because it often determines the level of comfort provided in relation to specific sleeping positions such as side, back, and stomach sleepers. Side sleepers will most likely prefer a mattress that’s softer on the hip and shoulder areas for targeted pressure relief. Stomach or back sleepers will benefit from the added support from a firmer mattress most because it promotes proper spinal alignment. Your size and weight can also factor in when determining how firm you want your mattress to be. If you are a smaller individual or a child, mattresses will most likely feel firmer to you but will feel softer to heavier or average-sized sleepers.
The Tuft and Needle mattress is generally considered to be a 5/10 on the firmness scale, with 10 being the firmest. The Tuft and Needle mattress promises a universal feel that should be comfortable and supportive in any sleeping position without feeling too soft or too firm. We think they did a great job executing their design goals and the medium-firm feel gives sleepers just the perfect amount of sinkage and balanced support.
The Casper mattress firmness is considered by most to be a solid 6 on the firmness scale, with 10 being the firmest. The Casper mattress aims to provide a firmness level that suits any sleep position and we agree that a firmness level of 6 does the job for almost any sleeper. The Casper mattress is soft enough for side sleepers and also firm enough to support the stomach or back sleepers. However, this firmness may not be quite enough for heavy individuals or larger couples and the same can be said for the Tuft and Needle mattress as well.
What we think: Choose the Casper mattress if you prefer a bed that’s a bit firmer and the Tuft Needle mattress if you are one of those sleepers who prefer a bed that’s on the softer side. Either way, each of these beds should accommodate almost any sleeper regardless of the sleeping position. Both the Tuft and Needle and the Casper mattress make for a great choice for couples who sleep in different positions or sleepers who shift and frequently change positions throughout the night.
Support often gets lumped with firmness when it comes to mattresses but there are key differences that make them important in facilitating quality sleep. How firm a mattress is, which we just discussed above, refers to the overall feel it provides whereas support refers to its ability to promote proper spinal alignment, regardless of whether it is soft or firm. Edge support can also be grouped into this category as it is an extension of ‘overall support.’ Proper edge support increases the usable surface area of your mattress and enables you to sit or lie on the edge of the bed without feeling like you could slide off entirely.
Tuft and Needle mattresses provide support to your body weight with their dual-layer foam construction. The layer of Adaptive foam provides support and comfort. The firmer, denser bottom layer is the durable foundation that prevents you from bottoming out when centralized pressure is applied. The base layer’s foam is also flexible enough to promote proper alignment of the spine without being too rigid for comfort whether you are a side, back, or stomach sleeper. These mattresses do not incorporate specific edge support but they do have firmer edges than your typical foam mattress; you should be able to utilize the entire surface of the bed without problems. The edge support should also be sufficient enough so that sleepers can easily get into and out of bed without excessive compression.
Casper takes this feature a notch higher by utilizing several techniques to provide ample support in their mattresses. Similar to Tuft and Needle, the majority of Casper’s support layer is derived from the dense, supportive foam serving as the base of the bed. However, Casper’s support layer base stands out because it employs contouring cuts and a 5-zoned support design to establish targeted amounts of support for your body weight in exactly the right places. For example, more support is given to the lumbar and hip region because that is where sleepers apply the most pressure to the surface of the bed. The zoned support system, paired with a layer of Adaptive transition foam to prevent bottoming out on the top layers of your Casper mattress. This helps to promote proper spine alignment so you can indulge in long, deep sleep, without having to worry about aches and pains.
The Casper mattress does not have any additional edge support in its design as the manufacturer claims added edge support is unnecessary in foam mattresses and simply a term invented for innerspring beds. Casper also states they chose to do away with hardening agents for edge support in an effort to be more environmentally and human-friendly. Regardless of their reasoning, the Casper mattress has enough edge support to support your weight across the surface of the bed when you are lying down, which is what Casper says it was designed for, not sitting.
What we think: If you’re looking for a mattress that provides more support, pick Casper. Casper definitely excels over Tuft and Needle in the support category, largely due to the former’s specialized zoned support design that features contouring cuts. This defining feature enhances support and helps distribute weight evenly throughout the bed surface.
Pressure Relief and Motion Isolation
Pressure relief is important for sleeping because it not only helps to make you comfortable, it also eliminates aches and pains in the morning caused by centralized pressure in heavier regions of your body while you sleep. Pressure relief can be visibly seen in a mattress through its ability to contour your shape, its responsiveness in relation to bounce, and its ability to eliminate motion transfer. Mattresses made from foam, regardless if they come in 2 or more layers, are not usually known for their bounciness and if you’re the type of sleeper who values this feature, you may want to consider a hybrid or a bouncier latex mattress.
The Tuft and Needle mattress provides accurate pressure relief through its Adaptive foam layer. The foam’s open-cell structure is flexible and moves with you as you shift positions during sleep. You can expect a mostly traditional foam feel from this mattress and it does an excellent job of contouring your shape for a more comfortable night’s sleep. We also observed that Adaptive foam may give a bit more bounce than regular memory foam. This bounciness, however, does not detract from its ability to minimize motion transfer, which this Tuft and Needle model also does very well.
The Casper mattress provides bounce with its top layer of open-cell foam which works to complement the pressure relief provided by the high-density memory foam layer. These layers work together to contour your shape while you sleep, giving a level of comfort and feel often attributed to a traditional mattress made out of foam. While there is a little more bounce than normal, the Casper mattress still does a great job minimizing motion transfer. This ensures you sleep comfortably despite staying in bed with a sleeper who frequently changes body positions at night.
What we think: For this round of the Casper vs Tuft Needle review, the Tuft and Needle mattress wins due to its excellent pressure relief, slight bounce, and ability to minimize motion transfer, thanks to its simple yet effective dual-layered foam design.
Temperature regulation is vital when it comes to getting quality sleep, particularly in foam beds which have a history of retaining heat. Many sleepers get hot in bed, some more than others. Choosing a mattress that addresses the needs of hot sleepers can be very beneficial for your overall comfort level.
Tuft and Needle takes a few different precautions when it comes to eliminating heat buildup as you sleep. First, it uses comfort layers that are inherently breathable, like its adaptive foam that’s topped by a breathable knit cover. Second, Tuft and Needle infused the top layer of foam with heat-wicking graphite to pull heat away from your body while you sleep. Third, the proprietary foam used is also packed with cooling gel beads which trap the heat away from your body while also keeping the bed surface cool. Sleepers that tend to sleep hotter than normal will definitely benefit from Tuft and Needle’s advanced temperature regulation capabilities.
Casper mattresses achieve temperature regulation by using materials that are inherently breathable. For instance, the polyester knit cover works to enhance airflow throughout the multi-layer mattress without trapping heat inside the bed. Furthermore, the breathable foam also does a great job of warding off excess heat, especially when compared to traditional memory foam. And when used with lightweight, low thread count and equally breathable sheets, overheating will never be a problem with the Casper mattress.
What we think: While the Casper mattress performs well when it comes to maintaining a cool sleeping environment, Tuft and Needle mattress does a better job of regulating temperature. Infusing one of the foam layers with graphite and cooling gel beads, in effect, lending the mattress superior heat-wicking and cooling capabilities is what convinced us most.
Keeping It Clean
Keeping your foam mattresses clean preserves the materials inside. A clean bed and mattress prevents rapid deterioration of the materials used and helps to keep you sleeping on a healthy, sanitary surface. Natural bacteria and dead skin pile up on your bed as you continually sleep in it and if not kept clean, may lead to minor illnesses that are often respiratory in nature. This is why you should keep your mattress as clean as possible.
Tuft and Needle mattresses do not have a removable cover but they can be spot cleaned. We recommend doing this seasonally or in the event of a spill or messy mishaps in bed.
Casper clearly likes to throw in a few extras and this time, it’s the convenient, machine washable, easy-to-remove knit cover durable enough to withstand years of use. The cover also has hidden handles sewn into the corners making it relatively easier to lift and move the mattress should the need arise.
What we think: For this category of our Casper vs Tuft Needle comparison, Casper wins hands down. Mattresses are meant to be used for years and the washable, easy-to-remove knit cover with nifty tucked handles is a nice addition we can’t help but appreciate.
Both the Tuft and Needle and Casper mattresses are affordable considering their top-of-the-line features. Neither of these mattresses is considered expensive but every dollar counts when it comes to making significant financial decisions such as purchasing a mattress.
Tuft & Needle is consistently lower in cost compared to Casper, but not by much. On average, the price difference is less than $50. The only time this isn’t true is for the King size, which is slightly less expensive with Casper.
What we think: The winner when it comes to affordability is the Tuft & Needle mattress. It is more affordable in nearly every variant based on size. If you want to save a little, choose Tuft and Needle UK or their online mattress store in the United States.
Size does matter when contemplating a new mattress purchase. While size isn’t the most important factor to consider when choosing mattresses, it certainly makes a big difference. For example, if you are planning on putting your new mattress in a small room, a room with odd dimensions, or if you plan to use a specific bed frame, size is of greater importance.
The Tuft & Needle Original mattress is available in the following sizes: Twin, Twin XL, Full, Queen, King, and California King.
The Casper Mattress is available in the following sizes: Single, EU Single, Small DoubleDouble, EU Double, King, EU King, and Super King.
What we think: The Casper mattress easily wins this round as it comes in a range of sizes to accommodate your room dimensions and your choice of the bed frame.
In-Home Trial and Warranty Length
Both Tuft and Needle and Casper provide a 100-night sleep trial with an industry-standard 10-year warranty. The sleep trial length is important for online shopping because it ensures you won’t be stuck with a mattress you don’t like. Not only that, an obligation-free trial period gives you the opportunity to find a bed that is perfect for your needs, without solely relying on online mattress reviews and information provided by the manufacturer.
The warranty for 10 years is equally important because it guarantees the company will stand behind their craftsmanship and commitment to you, the consumer. The warranty also alerts you to the expected durability of the mattress which can be factored into the price. We think the warranty length is reasonable because you will probably want to replace your mattress with a newer one for health reasons, even if it’s still usable after 10 years.
What we think: It’s a tie! Both the Casper and the Tuft and Needle mattress provide a sleep trial for 100 nights and a warranty for 10 years that covers sagging, factory defects, and certain physical flaws.
Shipping and Delivery Process
Tuft and Needle mattresses come with a free delivery and returns offer when you purchase a new bed. All mattresses arrive packed and rolled in a box for easy transfer. Tuft & Needle claims almost all mattresses are shipped within 1-5 business days after the initial order is placed. Additionally, some US cities are eligible for same-day delivery for an additional cost of $50. Tuft and Needle also offers a white glove delivery service for $150 which includes a scheduled delivery date and time, set up, removal of trash and packaging, in addition to removal of your old mattress.
Casper mattresses also use the bed-in-a-box shipping model and come with free delivery at no additional cost. If you prefer a more personalized delivery service, simply upgrade to Premium Delivery which allows you to schedule the date for delivery. This premium service also includes a two-hour delivery time slot that is determined as your scheduled delivery date approaches. The Casper Premium Delivery also includes removal of packaging and new mattress set up all for a very affordable $20 fee. Additionally, you can opt to have the delivery team remove your old mattress for only $15.
What we think: Casper definitely has the best shipping offers for their customers. While both mattress companies provide free shipping with every mattress purchase, Casper’s upgraded delivery options are more cost-effective than what Tuft & Needle offers.
Now that you have read our full Tuft and Needle vs Casper mattress review, it’s time to tally up the score and see where each mattress excels, so we can determine the overall winner.
First, let’s check where Tuft and Needle stands out. Tuft and Needle provides sleepers with a medium-firm universal feel that is designed to accommodate any sleeping position. Based on our reviews, it is a tad softer than the Casper mattress. However, it possesses superior pressure relief, contour, and essentially eliminates motion transfer with its durable and responsive foam components. Tuft and Needle also provides sleepers with advanced and highly effective temperature regulation by way of heat-wicking and heat-trapping graphite and cooling gel bead infusions.
Now let’s look at Casper’s strengths. Casper also aims to provide sleepers with a universal medium-firm feel that accommodates all sleeping positions, though the mattress is slightly firmer than their Tuft and Needle counterpart. The Casper prioritizes targeted support in 5 different zones which also allows for excellent pressure relief, contour, and motion isolation. The Casper also has an easy-to-remove cover which helps prolong the mattress’ lifespan. Additionally, Casper offers a wide variety of sizing options to choose from in addition to affordable shipping upgrade options.
The Results Are In….
The overall winner of this comparison is Casper! Casper is significantly better than the competition, thanks to its superior temperature regulation properties and value-added features such as the removable breathable cover, sizing options, and upgradable top-notch shipping and delivery service.
While we know there are lots of mattress reviews online, we hope this one helped you determine what makes a mattress a great buy for most sleepers. Hopefully, you are now ready to make a decision based on what you value most in a bed, unless, of course, you’re also considering other products such as the Leesa Mattress.
All things considered, we think the Casper and the T&N mattresses offer great value-for-money features. Both mattresses are excellent choices for discerning consumers like you!